My results September - December 2014

1000_ Part 1 1000_Part 2 1000_Part 3 1000_ Part 4

Comments / Комментарии

Posted by Perky on
Do you provide signals?
Posted by Janna FX on
------------------------ Perky ------------------------------

Not at this moment.
Posted by botrader on
Hi janna.

I really think you have talent and id like to share a website with you so your followers can copy your trades it is www.zulutrade.co.uk if that is ok. I have been watching your videos and practice your strategy very well and you have to be one of thebest traders with consistent and thoughtful trading. Ihave study many traders on zulu trade and each and every one so far blows up customer accounts with huge drawdowns and guess work. You have real control over your trading and i for one would feel 110% comfortable following a trader with such talent like yourself. I also really enjoy your travels.

All the best

Bo
Posted by Janna FX on
----------------- botrader ----------------------------

Hi Bo,

thanks, I might offer in the future a possibility of following my trades, but at this moment I still do not trade regularly, as I continue travelling.
Posted by Peter on
Hi Janna,

I have spent some time checking these results that you post here with the MetaTrader Strategy Tester, where you can review all the old market data.

I have selected data for the whole month of September 2014.

I found out that you have more than one of your operations are, at least "suspicious"....

Let me explain myself:

For example, according to your posted results, on the row number 7 from the top you have an operation with this data:

Buy operation on EUR/USD
Open time: 2014-09-12 at 12:42:02
Open price = 1.29443 (ON MT4 THE PRICE IS NEVER AT THAT LEVEL AT THAT DAY/HOUR)
T/P = 1.29543
S/L = 1.29143

Now the most interesting part....

Your open time is at 2014-09-04 at 12:42:02 and CLOSE TIME is at 12:44:52 (THAT MEANS 2 MINS AFTER)

According to MetaTrader4 data the price is never on those levels at that day/hour and in addition, the price is not jumping from your open price to your take-proffit IN 2 MINS...

Can you please explain this??

Thanks.
Posted by Peter on
Hi Janna,

I have spent some time checking these results that you post here with the MetaTrader Strategy Tester, where you can review all the old market data.

I have selected data for the whole month of September 2014.

I found out that you have more than one of your operations are, at least "suspicious"....

Let me explain myself:

For example, according to your posted results, on the row number 7 from the top you have an operation with this data:

Buy operation on EUR/USD
Open time: 2014-09-12 at 12:42:02
Open price = 1.29443 (ON MT4 THE PRICE IS NEVER AT THAT LEVEL AT THAT DAY/HOUR)
T/P = 1.29543
S/L = 1.29143

Now the most interesting part....

Your open time is at 2014-09-04 at 12:42:02 and CLOSE TIME is at 12:44:52 (THAT MEANS 2 MINS AFTER)

According to MetaTrader4 data the price is never on those levels at that day/hour and in addition, the price is not jumping from your open price to your take-proffit IN 2 MINS...

Can you please explain this??

Thanks.
Posted by Janna FX on
-------------------------------------- Peter -------------------------------------

Hi Peter,

All brokers have they own prices...
Posted by Peter on
Dear Janna,

Your answer is basically explaining nothing....
Posted by Janna FX on
-------------------------------------- Peter -------------------------------------

Peter, Forex is not a centralized market. That means brokers get pricing from different sources as each broker will use a different liquidity pool. That is why many strategies work with some brokers and not with others.
MT4 history is provided by metaquotes, not your own broker, which is why you can't use it for historical analysis.
That is why I do not use history, if you watched my videos you would see I use the same broker and my trades were made in real time, this is not a back-test.
Posted by Defx on
Hi Janna, you have a very good win rate. I'm a beginner and still learning. I'm just wondering how long does take for you to achieve the consistency in trading?

Thank you
You must be logged in to leave a reply. Login »